Open Offices: Ruining Productivity, Lives, Since the '50s

Open offices are bad for us: they make us less productive, less healthy, and less happy to be at work. Ample research suggests that we'd be better off returning to the days of offices with doors -- or, at the very least cubicles with higher walls. So why is the open office so popular?

open office 

(Photo Credit: Phillie Casablanca/Flickr)

A recent New Yorker article examines research on open-plan offices, and determines -- no surprise -- that privacy and quiet are actually pretty important when you're trying to create just about anything.

"The open office was originally conceived by a team from Hamburg, Germany, in the nineteen-fifties, to facilitate communication and idea flow," writes Maria Konnikova. "But a growing body of evidence suggests that the open office undermines the very things that it was designed to achieve."

That body of evidence comprises several studies, including:

  • A 2010 study that found that noise reduces cognitive performance.
  • Research from 2012 that found a link between office noise and workers' reduced ability to think.
  • A 2011 study from Denmark that described a connection between the number of people in a room, and the number of workers taking sick leave.

Even committed multitaskers have issues with open offices, according to Konnikova, who quotes cognitive neuroscientist Anthony Wagner's findings that multitaskers are "more susceptible to interference from irrelevant environmental stimuli." Bottom line: no matter how social you are, or how efficient you are at switching between tasks, too much noise and commotion are going to reduce your productivity.

None of this is a secret, of course. Why, finally, do companies continue to opt for open plans?

In short, money. Open offices allow companies to cram in as many workers as they need, without making a significant investment in equipment.

For those of us who hate open offices, the challenge will be to convince the boss that the loss of productivity associated with working without walls costs more than open plans save.

Tell Us What You Think

Open offices: yea or nay? We want to hear from you! Leave a comment or join the discussion on Twitter.


  1. 3 Yap 31 Jan
    I agree, open offices sounds like the man is trying to watch you. It
    would make you suicidal and bring down the morale of the  employees. Why
    would I want to sit that close to someone? What if someone has really
    bad gas that day? I can't see how this would increase revenue and
    productivity in a company.
  2. 2 ItWillNeverHappen 25 Jan
    Even a minimal amount of common sense would tell anyone that, for 99% of work types, open offices are the worst possible environment for getting anything done.  In my experience, however, it is not just the up-front cost savings that has made this nonsense so popular, it is management, particularly middle and upper management, who have a "The Employee Is The Enemy" attitude - if they can't watch all of us like a hawk, we will surely all goof off, surf the net, and take naps instead of working.  Thus, no private offices, and certainly no work-from-home.  This saves Management the trouble of actually having to to THEIR jobs by knowing what their employees are doing and who is actually being productive.  Hire more competent Managers, and the "open office" concept will die a quick and well-deserved death.
  3. 1 Necole 16 Jan

    I absolutely hate open offices. I can't get anything done. People pop gum, play music or talk loudly on the phone. It's miserable and we all share colds/flu's.


  1. Please prove to us that you're not a robot:

Find Out Exactly What You Should Be Paid

United States (change)

Comp Managers: Start Here »