When Discrimination Is Allowed: About Bona Fide Occupational Qualifications
As a general rule, employers are not allowed to discriminate based on certain factors like sex and sometimes age. However, what many people do not understand is that anti-discrimination laws like the Civil Rights Act or the Age Discrimination in Employment Act actually do allow for discrimination under some circumstances. One time employers are allowed to discriminate is if they are doing so because of a “bona fide occupational qualification.” Both federal and most state anti-discrimination laws also allow for this defense.
(Photo Credit: goMainstream/Flickr)
What Is a Bona Fide Occupational Qualification?
Normally, employers are not allowed to consider certain characteristics when making employment decisions like whom to hire, whom to fire, and whom to promote. Usually, people cannot be discriminated against due to their sex or due to their being “too old.” But in some very rare circumstances, these characteristics actually affect a person’s ability to do a job. When that is the case, being of a certain age or sex may actually be a bona fide occupational qualification, and discrimination may be allowed. Generally speaking, the bona fide occupational qualification must be reasonably necessary to the normal operation of the business. Merely satisfying customers is not always a good enough reason under this standard, as was demonstrated by a line of cases involving airlines who wanted to hire exclusively female flight attendants.
What Are Some Examples Bona Fide Occupational Qualifications?
The easiest example of an industry where bona fide occupational qualifications come up all the time is in modeling. If a designer has created a line of women’s clothes, then she can specifically seek out women to model those clothes. Another example includes a limited set of mandatory retirement ages. While most companies cannot set a mandatory age of retirement, airlines may do so for their pilots for safety reasons.
So What About Race?
The one characteristic that cannot ever be a bona fide occupational qualification is race. The premise is that a person’s race can really never affect his or her ability to do a job. But this does not mean that absolutely no employers can ever consider race. The right to artistic expression covered by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution overrides anti-discrimination laws. So if, for example, a film studio were making a biographical movie about Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and his struggles as an African-American for racial justice, then the movie studio could specifically seek out black actors to play Dr. King.
Tell Us What You Think
Do you know someone who has been denied a job because of the person’s race, sex, or disability status? We want to hear from you! Leave a comment or join the discussion on Twitter.