The significant raise comes when they have to match someone else's offer
Financial Analyst - (City withheld for privacy), England: London, United Kingdom
The best advice is to get an other offer. I have been quantitatively and qualitatively ahead of my collegues on most criteria that we are measured on, but that does not determine your salary. Get an offer from a competitor and they are quick to realise your real worth. However, be prepared to leave if they don't.