Get a Salary Report for

- Compare Your Salary
- Evaluate a Job Offer

- Price a New Hire
- Give a Raise

- Benchmark Jobs
- Create a Comp Plan

Average Salary for American Family Insurance Group Employees

Operating out of Pueblo, Colorado, insurance company American Family Insurance Group employs talent in positions ranging from Insurance Agent to Senior Claims Adjuster. Employees at American Family Insurance Group make $51K per year on average. Where you live influences pay for American Family Insurance Group workers the most, followed by your experience level and your role at the company. This report is based on answers to PayScale's salary questionnaire.

How This Employer Pays

American Family Insurance Group typically pays:
at market
Similar employers pay:
below market
Employer: American Family Insurance Group
Average Salary Range by Job
Job (Number Reporting)
National Data (?
XAll compensation data shown are gross, national 10th to 90th percentile ranges. Pay can vary greatly by location. To view local data, take the PayScale survey.
[-]Insurance Agent (9)
$26,670 - $97,581  
[-]Insurance Agent (9)
Salary$28,623 - $93,512  
Bonus$345.88 - $14,293  
Commission$665 - $26,792  
Total Pay$26,670 - $97,581  
[+]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
$20,953 - $46,574  
[+]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
Bonus$146.93 - $4,144  
Total Pay$20,953 - $46,574  
[+]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (6)
$19,327 - $40,743  
[+]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (6)
Total Pay$19,327 - $40,743  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (4)
$45,393 - $87,412  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (4)
Salary$45,466 - $83,973  
Bonus$1,072 - $10,839  
Total Pay$45,393 - $87,412  
 Precise Range (?
XPrecise ranges are calculated based on validated data submitted by employees in this job at this company.
)     Estimated Range (?
XWhen PayScale has limited employee-submitted data, we base estimated ranges on a broader set of relevant employee profiles to calculate the most accurate ranges for this job at this company.
Country: United States | Currency: USD | Updated: 9 Nov 2014 | Individuals Reporting: 81
United States (change)

American Family Insurance Group Details

Pueblo, Colorado




American Family Insurance

Suggest changes »

Freebase CC-BY Source: Freebase, licensed under CC-BY


When it comes to location, the highest average paycheck ($100K annually) can be spotted in Atlanta; Minneapolis ($79K), Madison (approximately $78K), and Chicago (around $65K) are the next top-paying cities. St. Louis ranks low on the pay scale — at $44K, it is one of the lowest-paid cities. By state, Wisconsin offers the highest pay at about $77K per year.

Years of Experience

Between the one and five year mark, pay is typically $52K. Respondents with a company tenure of five to ten years tend to make around $65K. For the most part, a representative employee at American Family Insurance Group has been working for 10-19 years and makes approximately $75K annually.


Nearing the top of the pay scale are Claims Adjusters, Senior Claims Adjusters, and Insurance Agents; while the first receives the highest median pay at about $58K, the other salaries come in at $57K and $50K, respectively.

Certifications and Degrees

Those lacking certification bring in much lower salaries than Certified ScrumMasters, who make $98K. Project Management Professionals with credentials can live quite comfortably; salaries come in at $91K per year. It pays to have a Master of Science (MS), Management Information Systems (MIS) at American Family Insurance Group — these employees make the most at approximately $69K annually.


Skill-wise, employees who report Microsoft Office as part of the toolkit report the most money, earning around $84K on average. One of the more prevalent skills at American Family Insurance Group is Customer Service, with close to one-fourth considering it a key competency. Employees also tend to round out their skills sets with Sales, Insurance, and Project Management.

Benefits and Perks

Paid sick days are a given for more than half of workers, but American Family Insurance Group rewards only about half of workers with paid vacation. With an eye toward the future, American Family Insurance Group offers several choices in retirement planning such as a 401(k) plan and a company pension plan. A majority of workers report having health insurance, and more than half of workers report having dental coverage. Perks also include a casual working environment, life insurance, and flexible hours.

Key Stats

61 %
39 %
$35,000 - $79,336
$37,095 - $94,201
Less than 1 year
1-4 years
5-9 years
10-19 years
20 years or more
Extremely satisfied
Rated 5 out of 5
based on 12 votes.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Salary and career advice to put you a step ahead.
newsletter icon

Thanks! We'll send you a welcome newsletter as soon as we can.

In the meantime, check out our research center.

Looks like your email already exists in our database.
Please log in here.

You are already logged in.


Get Career Tips & Advice

Want to Get More Specific? Get a Salary Report Customized for YOU

Tell us about your current job and your skillset, and we'll let you know how much your employers are paying in your area.