What am I worth?
Get a free salary report »
What should I pay?
Pay the right way »

Average Salary for American Family Insurance Group Employees

Headquartered in Pueblo, Colo., American Family Insurance Group offers a range of employment opportunities in the insurance, from Senior Claims Adjuster to Claims Adjuster. The median salary at American Family Insurance Group is $54K per year. American Family Insurance Group paychecks are largely negotiated based on your city, though your job title and your experience level are also considered. This report is based on answers to PayScale's salary questionnaire.

Read More

How This Employer Pays

American Family Insurance Group typically pays:
below market
Similar employers pay:
at market
Employer: American Family Insurance Group
Average Salary Range by Job
Job (Number Reporting)
National Data (?
XAll compensation data shown are gross, national 10th to 90th percentile ranges. Pay can vary greatly by location. To view local data, take the PayScale survey.
[-]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (9)
$19,660 - $37,305  
[-]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (9)
Bonus$97.78 - $2,380  
Total Pay$19,660 - $37,305  
[+]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
$21,113 - $47,067  
[+]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
Bonus$14.67 - $2,760  
Commission$204.94 - $7,245  
Total Pay$21,113 - $47,067  
[+]Insurance Agent (7)
$23,188 - $80,238  
[+]Insurance Agent (7)
Salary$27,495 - $88,154  
Bonus$492.84 - $15,297  
Total Pay$23,188 - $80,238  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (6)
$46,757 - $87,861  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (6)
Salary$46,322 - $84,938  
Bonus$970 - $10,807  
Total Pay$46,757 - $87,861  
 Precise Range (?
XPrecise ranges are calculated based on validated data submitted by employees in this job at this company.
)     Estimated Range (?
XWhen PayScale has limited employee-submitted data, we base estimated ranges on a broader set of relevant employee profiles to calculate the most accurate ranges for this job at this company.
Country: United States | Currency: USD | Updated: 29 Mar 2015 | Individuals Reporting: 97

Find Out Exactly What You Should Be Paid

United States (change)

- OR -

Log in with LinkedIn

Comp Managers Click Here »

About This Company

Pueblo, Colorado 




American Family Insurance

Freebase CC-BY Source: Freebase, licensed under CC-BY


When it comes to location, the highest average paycheck ($100K annually) can be spotted in Atlanta, Ga.; Madison, Wisc. ($77K), Minneapolis, Minn. (about $74K), and Denver, Colo. (approximately $63K) are the next top-paying cities. Expected earnings are below average (around $57K) in St. Louis, Mo., one of the lowest-paid cities. By state, American Family Insurance Group employees make the most in Wisconsin, earning $77K per year on average.


Insurance Agents are the best paid with the average salary hovering at around $85K annually; Senior Applications Engineers, Senior Claims Adjusters, and Claims Adjusters also rank near the top of the list, pulling in $76K, approximately $63K, and about $51K, respectively.

Years of Experience

Average pay is $65K per year for those with five to nine years of experience. For those with one to four years of experience, median paychecks reach $50K annually. The largest slice of the American Family Insurance Group workforce (32 percent) has been working for 20 years or more and earns, on average, approximately $79K per year.

Certifications and Degrees

Certified ScrumMasters earn $98K annually, far more than their non-accredited counterparts. Earning a Project Management Professional certification garners significant financial rewards of $91K per year on average. Employees who have a Bachelor's Degree make the most here, hauling in $71K annually.


When it comes to skills, Microsoft Excel seems to bolster pay the most; employees who claim proficiency also enjoy a median income of about $83K per year. Customer Service is a popular skill in the American Family Insurance Group workforce; close to a sixth of those surveyed report putting it to use in their jobs. Some other standard skills here are Claim Handling, Project Management, and Data Analysis.

Benefits and Perks

A lucky few (37 percent) are fortunate enough to be compensated for both vacation and sick time. Quite a few retirement plans are on offer at American Family Insurance Group, including a 401(k) plan and a company pension plan. American Family Insurance Group provides health insurance to a majority of survey participants, and the larger part of survey participants do receive dental coverage. American Family Insurance Group employees also enjoy perks such as life insurance, a casual working environment, and flexible hours.

Key Stats for American Family Insurance Group


50 %
50 %
$48,479 - $81,380
$40,851 - $90,856
Less than 1 year
1-4 years
5-9 years
10-19 years
20 years or more

Job Satisfaction

Highly satisfied
Rated 4 out of 5
based on 15 votes.
United States (change)

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Salary and career advice to put you a step ahead.
newsletter icon


Recent Blog Posts on Career News

Want to Get More Specific? Get a Salary Report Customized for YOU

Tell us about your current job and your skillset, and we’ll let you know how much employers are paying in your area.