Average Salary for American Family Insurance Group Employees

Pueblo, Colo.-based American Family Insurance Group hires for positions ranging from Insurance Agent to Senior Claims Adjuster in the insurance sector. A salary of $53K per year is the going rate at American Family Insurance Group. At American Family Insurance Group, the biggest piece of the paycheck puzzle is your city — it impacts salary more than anything else — though your experience level and what you do at the company each factor into the equation as well. The data for this report comes from responses to the PayScale salary survey.

Read More

How This Employer Pays

American Family Insurance Group typically pays:
below market
Similar employers pay:
below market
Employer: American Family Insurance Group
Average Salary Range by Job
Job (Number Reporting)
National Data (?
XAll compensation data shown are gross, national 10th to 90th percentile ranges. Pay can vary greatly by location. To view local data, take the PayScale survey.
[-]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
$21,488 - $46,471  
[-]Insurance Agent Assistant (8)
Bonus$61.68 - $4,136  
Total Pay$21,488 - $46,471  
[+]Insurance Agent (8)
$25,119 - $95,004  
[+]Insurance Agent (8)
Salary$28,184 - $92,841  
Bonus$418.71 - $21,263  
Commission$602 - $27,446  
Total Pay$25,119 - $95,004  
[+]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (6)
$19,431 - $40,939  
[+]Customer Service Representative (CSR) (6)
Total Pay$19,431 - $40,939  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (5)
$46,372 - $86,668  
[+]Senior Claims Adjuster (5)
Salary$45,879 - $83,734  
Bonus$1,042 - $10,159  
Total Pay$46,372 - $86,668  
 Precise Range (?
XPrecise ranges are calculated based on validated data submitted by employees in this job at this company.
)     Estimated Range (?
XWhen PayScale has limited employee-submitted data, we base estimated ranges on a broader set of relevant employee profiles to calculate the most accurate ranges for this job at this company.
Country: United States | Currency: USD | Updated: 21 Nov 2014 | Individuals Reporting: 86
United States (change)

About This Company

Pueblo, Colorado 




American Family Insurance

Freebase CC-BY Source: Freebase, licensed under CC-BY


When it comes to location, the highest average paycheck ($100K annually) can be spotted in Atlanta; Madison ($78K), Minneapolis (approximately $74K), and Chicago (around $65K) are the next top-paying cities. St. Louis is one of the lowest-paid cities, with earnings averaging $44K. Across American Family Insurance Group's U.S. offices, employees in the state of Wisconsin earn the most, taking home about $77K per year.

Years of Experience

For those with five to nine years of experience, average earnings amount to approximately $65K. Workers who have been with the company for more than one year but less than five can typically make about $52K. Overall, the greater share of American Family Insurance Group folks have 10-19 years of experience and earn around $75K annually.


The highest paychecks go to Insurance Agents, who earn $60K, closely trailed by Claims Adjusters ($58K) and Senior Claims Adjusters ($58K).

Certifications and Degrees

Monetary compensation comes to about $98K for Certified ScrumMasters, far surpassing the earnings of non-credentialed workers. Earning a Project Management Professional certification garners significant financial rewards of approximately $91K per year. At American Family Insurance Group, employees who hold a Master of Science (MS), Management Information Systems (MIS) receive the highest salaries at $69K.


Employees who count Microsoft Office among their skills tend to enjoy higher pay; the median for this group is around $84K. One of the more prevalent skills at American Family Insurance Group is Customer Service, with somewhere between a fifth and a fourth considering it a key competency. Key skills also include Insurance, Sales, and Project Management.

Benefits and Perks

With an eye toward the future, American Family Insurance Group offers several choices in retirement planning such as a 401(k) plan and a company pension plan. As for time away from work, American Family Insurance Group does compensate more than half of workers for sick days, but only half of workers can take paid time off for vacation. For a majority of workers, benefits include health insurance, and more than half of workers get dental coverage, too. Privileges also include a casual working environment, life insurance, and flexible hours.

Key Stats for American Family Insurance Group


60 %
40 %
$35,000 - $79,336
$37,095 - $94,201
Less than 1 year
1-4 years
5-9 years
10-19 years
20 years or more

Job Satisfaction

Extremely satisfied
Rated 5 out of 5
based on 12 votes.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Salary and career advice to put you a step ahead.
newsletter icon


Recent Blog Posts on Career News

Want to Get More Specific? Get a Salary Report Customized for YOU

Tell us about your current job and your skillset, and we’ll let you know how much employers are paying in your area.