Average Salary for American Family Insurance Group Employees

American Family Insurance Group is a insurance firm headquartered in Pueblo, Colo. that hires for Insurance Claims Adjuster positions, Customer Service Representative roles, and more. An average American Family Insurance Group employee can expect to make $46K annually. For the most part, employee paychecks at American Family Insurance Group fluctuate depending on your role at the company; how long you've been working and where you live also matter, but to a lesser degree. This report is based on responses to the PayScale salary survey.

Read More
American Family Insurance Group Median Salary by Job


Insurance Claims Adjuster
6 profiles

Insurance Agent
5 profiles

Customer Service Representative (CSR)
3 profiles

Claims Adjuster / Examiner / Investigator
3 profiles

Insurance Sales Agent
3 profiles

Claims Adjuster
2 profiles

Software Engineer
2 profiles

  • Currency: USD
  • Updated: 15 Jul 2017
  • Individuals Reporting: 86
  • View Table

Find Out Exactly What You Should Be Paid

United States (change)

Employers: Start Here »

Find out more about pay at American Family Insurance Group

About This Company

Pueblo, Colorado 




American Family Insurance

Source: Freebase


The highest average salaries go to Claims Examiners and Investigators, who bring in close to $73K per year, though Software Engineers are not far behind at about $59K along with Insurance Agents ($55K) and Insurance Claims Adjusters (approximately $55K). On the lower end are Insurance Sales Agents at around $24K on average.

Years of Experience

For those with five to nine years of experience, average earnings amount to $74K annually. The largest fraction of American Family Insurance Group people (31 percent) have been working for one to four years and earn $54K per year on average.


When it comes to location, the highest average paycheck ($80K annually) can be spotted in St. Louis, Mo.; Madison, Wisc. (around $80K), Colorado Springs, Colo. ($73K), and Atlanta, Ga. (approximately $56K) are the next top-paying cities. Those interested in increasing earning potential should avoid the city of St. Joseph, Mo. — at about $50K, salaries are some of the lowest in the country. By state, the highest compensation levels appear in Wisconsin, where the average salary is $77K per year.

Certifications and Degrees

Certified Public Accountants have significantly higher pay than non-accredited workers at about $76K annually. Becoming an I-CAR Certification can certainly pay off here; those folks make $63K on average. American Family Insurance Group workers who hold a Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) are also well compensated, earning $88K on average.


The highest-paying skill in this position seems to be Microsoft Office; individuals who report it as part of the repertoire have a median income of approximately $84K per year. A skill that is commonly seen around here is Insurance; just under a third deem it necessary for work. Customer Service, Claim Handling, and Negotiation round out the set of key employee skills.

Benefits and Perks

Company benefits — namely paid time off for both vacation and sick leave — are received by just a fifth of employees. Employees looking to save up for old age can choose from several options including a 401(k) plan and a company pension plan. Health insurance comes as part of the deal for a little over a half of workers, and close to one-half report receiving dental coverage as well. Perks also include a casual working environment, flexible hours, and life insurance.

American Family Insurance Group Job Listings

Key Stats for American Family Insurance Group


59 %
41 %
$27,812 - $87,929
$24,765 - $70,000

Job Satisfaction

Highly satisfied
Rated 4 out of 5
based on 34 votes.
Less than 1 year
1-4 years
5-9 years
10-19 years
20 years or more
Years in Fields/Career:
United States (change)

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Salary and career advice to put you a step ahead.
newsletter icon


Recent Blog Posts on Career News

Want to Get More Specific? Get a Salary Report Customized for YOU

Tell us about your current job and your skillset, and we’ll let you know how much employers are paying in your area.