Back To Career News

3 Reasons to Love ‘Temp-to-Hire’ — and 3 Reasons to Hate It

As the economy improves, many employers are staffing up again, sometimes on a temp-to-hire basis. So is this good for employees, or just another way to work like a full-timer, without a full-timer's benefits?

As the economy improves, many employers are staffing up again, sometimes on a temp-to-hire basis. So is this good for employees, or just another way to work like a full-timer, without a full-timer’s benefits?

job maze 

(Photo Credit: Stuart Miles/freedigitalphotos.net)

“Companies … [have] used temporary [workers] and the temp-to-hire approach quite a bit,” says Ryan Skubis, South Florida district president for Robert Half International, in an interview with the Florida Sun Sentinel.

Do You Know What You're Worth?

Employers like temp-to-hire for obvious reasons: it cuts down on benefit costs, allows them to try out a worker to see if he or she is a good fit, and offers time to figure out if a full-time hire is warranted. Workers have reasons to like the arrangement, too, but it’s not without its downsides.

Pros:

1. Time to figure out if you like the job.

Anyone who’s ever had a stellar interview and then disliked the job later knows that you can’t always tell whether you’ll like a job until you’re doing it. You can research the employer until the cows come home, but nothing guarantees a good fit. Temp jobs allow you to try the gig on for size, before you commit.

2. Resume-building.

Temp jobs in your field are good stop-gaps for a resume that might otherwise look like a piece of Swiss cheese. Plus, you might get a chance to develop new skills, while keeping your existing skills honed.

3. Money.

Those unemployment checks only cover so much.

Cons:

1. You’re on probation.

It’s hard to feel comfy in a job when you know, flat-out, that you’re there on a trial basis. The old adage is true: If you don’t make mistakes, you’re not working hard enough. However, when you’re making mistakes in your temporary job, you’re liable to wind up pretty panicky. That sense of “one false move, and…” isn’t exactly the greatest environment for creativity.

2. You probably won’t get health benefits.

Employers love temp-to-hire for this reason, but if you’re shelling out for COBRA or private health insurance, you likely won’t feel the same way.

3. You could wind up making less if you get hired.

Quick: what’s your day rate? If you’re not an experienced contractor, you probably don’t know. And if you don’t prepare ahead of time, you might name a figure that’s significantly lower than it should be, given what your former employers shelled out for benefits and social security, etc.

Carol Tice of Make a Living Writing offers a good formula for calculating your rates, even for folks who aren’t in the writing business:

  • Analyze all the components of your full-time job pay package.
  • Calculate all the items you have to pay for as a freelancer that you didn’t as a staffer.

The later should include every single thing your company paid for, from healthcare to sick time to FLMA leave to per diems. Forgetting to add that in will cost you in the short run, and again in the long run when you (hopefully) negotiate your full-time pay.

Tell Us What You Think

Have you ever started a job as temp-to-hire? Leave a comment or join the discussion on Twitter.

Jen Hubley Luckwaldt
Read more from Jen

2
Leave a Reply

avatar
2 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
Marie WatsonGreg Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Marie Watson
Guest
Marie Watson

Thanks for pointing out some of the pros and cons of “temp-to-hire” positions. Even though you can be on trial for that sort of job, I like that it also gives you the opportunity to put the job and company on trial to figure out if it is the right fit for you as well. You also make a good point about how it can be a good resume builder. I think I would definitely take a temp-to-hire position. http://birkstaffinginc.com/job-seekers/

Greg
Guest
Greg

In a good economy, the statements in this article were kind of true. But in this state of the economy, it’s no longer temp work, but perma-temps. That’s where you can be working for a company for two or more years and still be a temp. There are no benefits, no job protection or workers rights and no future. We have gone back to the time before union rights. When a person can be a manager and a temp at the same time, something is wrong. s Now temps fill permanent positions. They work for less wages because the temp… Read more »

What Am I Worth?

What your skills are worth in the job market is constantly changing.