It takes time to change perceptions, and sometimes bias persists even when we’re not fully conscious of it. For this reason, researchers from Indiana University and the University of Maryland recently sought to discover what Americans really think about some traditional gender roles and duties. Let’s take a closer look at this study to see what it revealed.
Researchers began by asking participants to read over a brief description of a family. The paragraph depicted a couple’s occupations, their working hours, hobbies and interests, and their pay. Here is an example:
Brian and Jennifer met five years ago and have been married for just over a year. Brian is a physical therapist at a hospital, bringing home about $57,500 a year, and Jennifer is a reporter for a local newspaper, bringing home about $25,250 a year. They are both very busy, each working 40 hours per week. Despite their busy schedules, they try to do things together regularly. In fact, one of the only reoccurring arguments they have is what to do on the weekend together. Brian usually wants to play basketball if they are going out, or watch an action movie if they are staying in. Instead, Jennifer would rather go shopping or watch a romantic comedy.
Other vignettes changed some of these traits. In some cases, the wife earned more than the husband, and same-sex couples were used in some cases too (with one partner being described as more traditionally “masculine” and the other being depicted as “more feminine”).
Once participants had been given time to read through the vignettes, they were prompted to decide which partner should be responsible for eight separate household chores. These included cooking, cleaning, laundry, outdoor chores, making auto repairs, washing dishes, grocery shopping, and managing household finances. They were also asked to weigh in about who ought to be responsible for various responsibilities related to child care such as attending to children’s physical needs, emotional needs, discipline, and who would be the best candidate for stay-at-home parenting.
The results of this research might not have surprised us in 1956, but in 2016 they’re a bit shocking. Let’s take a look at some of the most important findings.
- For heterosexual couples, gender was the biggest factor in how chores and childcare were assigned — not income or the amount of hours worked. (The “gendered hobbies and interests” didn’t have as much effect as gender either.)
- Nearly 75 percent of respondents expressed that they felt the female partner should be responsible for cooking, doing the laundry, grocery shopping, and cleaning the house.
- Nearly 90 percent felt that the men in heterosexual couples should be responsible for automobile repairs and outdoor chores.
- When it came to same-sex couples, “traditionally female chores” were assigned to the partner who had been described in more traditionally feminine ways, and the others were assigned to the “more masculine” partner.
- The results were just as striking when it came to childcare. Sixty-two percent said the woman should be the stay-at-home parent, 82 percent said she should be responsible for the children’s physical needs, and 72 percent said she ought to be the one most responsible for attending to their emotional needs.
As disappointing and depressing as these results may be, taking an honest look at our own conceptions and biases is an essential first step in building toward equality. By taking a good hard look at where we are now, we can begin to question our beliefs, and then we can start to shift them.
For more information, be sure to check out the public release on this study, which shares more of the results.
Tell Us What You Think
How do you think household responsibilities should be divided? We want to hear from you! Leave a comment or join the discussion on Twitter.