Average Salary for American Family Insurance Group Employees

American Family Insurance Group is a insurance firm headquartered in Pueblo, Colo. that hires for Insurance Claims Adjuster positions, Customer Service Representative roles, and more. An average American Family Insurance Group employee can expect to make $46K annually. For the most part, employee paychecks at American Family Insurance Group fluctuate depending on your role at the company; how long you've been working and where you live also matter, but to a lesser degree. This report is based on responses to the PayScale salary survey.

Read More
American Family Insurance Group Median Salary by Job


Insurance Claims Adjuster
5 profiles

Insurance Agent
4 profiles

Insurance Producer
3 profiles

United States (change)

Insurance Sales Agent
3 profiles

Claims Adjuster / Examiner / Investigator
3 profiles

Senior Claims Adjuster
3 profiles

Customer Service Representative (CSR)
3 profiles

See all degrees for American Family Insurance Group »
  • Currency: USD
  • Updated: 08 Nov 2017
  • Individuals Reporting: 91
  • View Table

Find out more about pay at American Family Insurance Group

About This Company

Pueblo, Colorado 




American Family Insurance

Source: Freebase


The highest average salaries go to Claims Examiners and Investigators, who bring in close to $73K per year, though Software Engineers are not far behind at about $59K along with Insurance Agents ($55K) and Insurance Claims Adjusters (approximately $55K). On the lower end are Insurance Sales Agents at around $24K on average.

Years of Experience

For those with five to nine years of experience, average earnings amount to $74K annually. The largest fraction of American Family Insurance Group people (31 percent) have been working for one to four years and earn $54K per year on average.


When it comes to location, the highest average paycheck ($80K annually) can be spotted in St. Louis, Mo.; Madison, Wisc. (around $80K), Colorado Springs, Colo. ($73K), and Atlanta, Ga. (approximately $56K) are the next top-paying cities. Those interested in increasing earning potential should avoid the city of St. Joseph, Mo. — at about $50K, salaries are some of the lowest in the country. By state, the highest compensation levels appear in Wisconsin, where the average salary is $77K per year.

Certifications and Degrees

Certified Public Accountants have significantly higher pay than non-accredited workers at about $76K annually. Becoming an I-CAR Certification can certainly pay off here; those folks make $63K on average. American Family Insurance Group workers who hold a Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) are also well compensated, earning $88K on average.


The highest-paying skill in this position seems to be Microsoft Office; individuals who report it as part of the repertoire have a median income of approximately $84K per year. A skill that is commonly seen around here is Insurance; just under a third deem it necessary for work. Customer Service, Claim Handling, and Negotiation round out the set of key employee skills.

Benefits and Perks

Company benefits — namely paid time off for both vacation and sick leave — are received by just a fifth of employees. Employees looking to save up for old age can choose from several options including a 401(k) plan and a company pension plan. Health insurance comes as part of the deal for a little over a half of workers, and close to one-half report receiving dental coverage as well. Perks also include a casual working environment, flexible hours, and life insurance.

American Family Insurance Group Job Listings

Key Stats for American Family Insurance Group


59 %
41 %
$27,812 - $87,929
$24,765 - $70,000

Job Satisfaction

Highly satisfied
Rated 4 out of 5
based on 34 votes.
Less than 1 year
1-4 years
5-9 years
10-19 years
20 years or more

Popular Locations for American Family Insurance Group

  1. Madison, Wisconsin
  2. Minneapolis, Minnesota
  3. Chicago, Illinois
  4. St. Joseph, Missouri
  5. St. Louis, Missouri
  6. Colorado Springs, Colorado
  7. Atlanta, Georgia

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Salary and career advice to put you a step ahead.

newsletter icon

Recent Blog Posts on Career News

Want to Get More Specific? Get a Salary Report Customized for YOU

Tell us about your current job and your skillset, and we’ll let you know how much employers are paying in your area.