Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company pays an average of $1,981 in annual employee bonuses. Bonus pay at Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company ranges from $500 to $50,000 annually among employees who report receiving a bonus. Employees with the title Senior Asset Manager earn the highest bonuses with an average annual bonus of $50,000. Employees with the title Customer Service Representative (CSR) earn the lowest bonuses with an average annual bonus of $500.