Average Claims Supervisor Salary

The top respondents for the job title Claims Supervisor are from the companies Geico, Farmers Insurance Group and UnitedHealth Group. Reported salaries are highest at Farmers Insurance Group where the average pay is $78,555. Other companies that offer high salaries for this role include Mercury Insurance Company and Progressive Casualty Insurance Company, earning around $75,243 and $73,851, respectively. UnitedHealth Group pays the lowest at around $50,676. Geico and Mercury also pay on the lower end of the scale, paying $62,095 and $69,634, respectively.

Skills in Claim Handling, Performance Management, Team Leadership and Negotiation are correlated to pay that is above average. Skills that pay less than market rate include People Management.

An entry-level Claims Supervisor with less than 1 year experience can expect to earn an average total compensation (includes tips, bonus, and overtime pay) of $50,301 based on 27 salaries. An early career Claims Supervisor with 1-4 years of experience earns an average total compensation of $53,477 based on 129 salaries. A mid-career Claims Supervisor with 5-9 years of experience earns an average total compensation of $59,579 based on 158 salaries. An experienced Claims Supervisor with 10-19 years of experience earns an average total compensation of $72,164 based on 216 salaries. In their late career (20 years and higher), employees earn an average total compensation of $79,383.

Employees with Claims Supervisor in their job title in San Diego, California earn an average of 18.4% more than the national average. These job titles also find higher than average salaries in Nashville, Tennessee (15.3% more) and Dallas, Texas (8.3% more). The lowest salaries can be found in Chicago, Illinois (14.3% less) and Tampa, Florida (4.5% less).